N. B There is no conference fee, and coffee/tea will be provided free. If you wish to have a buffet lunch, there will be a £5.00 charge on the day.
Contact Piotr Bienkowski on firstname.lastname@example.org for further information.
To book your place at the conference, please email or telephone:
Anna Davey (Events and Marketing Co-ordinator)
0161 275 8788
RESPECT FOR ANCIENT BRITISH HUMAN REMAINS:
PHILOSOPHY AND PRACTICE
A conference organised by The Manchester Museum (University of Manchester) and Honouring the Ancient Dead, supported by the Museums Association
Manchester Museum, Friday 17th November 2006
It is becoming standard practice for UK museums to repatriate human remains to their originating communities in Australasia and North America for reburial. An emerging issue, hotly debated, concerns the British counterparts of those remains: the communities for whom they are important are advocating with museums and archaeologists for respectful treatment, storage and sometimes reburial of ancient British human remains, both those recently excavated and those accessioned long ago and held in museum stores.
The rationale for archaeologists excavating human remains, and museums collecting, studying and displaying them, is that they contribute to understanding of human history and that their analysis advances scientific knowledge in various fields. But the rights of science, archaeology and museums to use dead bodies as a research and teaching resource are not universally accepted. For many communities, human remains are sacred, they contain the stories of individuals, peoples, and landscapes. From that perspective, they must be treated with respect, and some question their use as objects of scientific investigation at all, or at the very least their continued storage in museums once research has been undertaken.
Museums and archaeologists are beginning to engage with various communities in the UK who experience the world in different ways, particularly pagan faith traditions, who feel an unbroken ancestral connection with ancient human remains and their landscapes, and are demanding respectful treatment for those remains. As a result, the assumptions, approaches, and practices of museums and archaeologists are being challenged and changed. In response, and in consultation with those communities, some museums are amending their policies and treatment of ancient British human remains, and in some instances reburying or seriously considering reburial.
This conference explores ideas of the sanctity of the human body and arguments for what constitutes respectful treatment within a robust philosophical, cultural and ethical framework. It offers practical guidance for museums and archaeologists on consultation, appropriate storage and treatment, and the process of reburial. Issues examined are:
Different ways of experiencing and understanding the world and humanity’s position within nature, and their implications for the meaning and treatment of human remains
Cultural attitudes towards sanctity of the human body
A critique of the attitude and practice of western archaeology towards human remains, using bog bodies as a case study
Analysis of pagan views of the sanctity of burial
Do modern pagan communities have a claim to be consulted and heard?
Are the age and cultural background and connections of human remains relevant?
Museum practices and processes regarding human remains
The benefits of scientific study and analysis of ancient human remains
A practical guide to respectful treatment, storage and reburial, including consultation, decision-making, funding, location, deaccessioning from museum collections, and associated rituals.
The conference speakers are museum directors and curators, archaeologists, academics, and the founder of Honouring the Ancient Dead, a British network organisation set up to advocate for respect towards ancient pagan human remains and related artefacts and create dialogue with museums and archaeologists.
Professor Piotr Bienkowski: Deputy Director, The Manchester Museum, and Professor of Archaeology and Museology, University of Manchester
Dr Jenny Blain: Senior Lecturer in Sociology, Division of Applied Social Science, Faculty of Development and Society, Sheffield Hallam University
Laura Coats: Senior Curator, History, Leicester City Museums
Dr Melanie Giles: Lecturer in Archaeology, University of Manchester
Sarah Levitt: Head of Museums Services, Leicester City Museums
Emma Restall Orr: Head of The Druid Network, founder and council member of Honouring the Ancient Dead
Professor Elizabeth Slater: Garstang Professor of Archaeology, and Dean of the Faculty of Arts, University of Liverpool
Dr Robert J. Wallis: Associate Professor of Visual Culture, and Associate Director, MA in Art History, Richmond the American University in London
09.00: Registration and coffee
09.30: Introduction (Emma Restall Orr and Piotr Bienkowski)
09.45: Persons, Things and Archaeology: Contrasting World-views of Minds, Bodies and Death (Piotr Bienkowski)
10.35: Coffee break
10.50: Cultural Attitudes Towards Sanctity of the Human Body (Emma Restall Orr)
11.40: Archaeology of Human Remains: Paradigm and Process (Melanie Giles)
13.15: The Sanctity of Burial: Pagan Views, Ancient and Modern (Jenny Blain and Robert J. Wallis)
14.05: Museums and Human Remains: Duty of Care, Consultation, Consent (Sarah Levitt and Laura Coats)
14.55: Tea break
15.10: The Benefits of Scientific Study and Analysis of Ancient Human Remains (Elizabeth Slater)
16.00: Respectful Treatment and Reburial: A Practical Guide (Emma Restall Orr and Piotr Bienkowski)
16.50: Discussion (mediated by Emma Restall Orr and Piotr Bienkowski)
17.30-18.00: Conference ends. Drinks reception.
The Attic (a name which commemorates our first physical location) is, first and foremost, a site for the research students of the School of Museum Studies at the University of Leicester: a virtual community which aims to include all students, be they campus-based and full-time, or distance-learning and overseas. But we welcome contributions from students of museum studies - and allied subject areas - from outside the School and from around the world. Here you will find a lot of serious stuff, like exhibition and research seminar reviews, conference alerts and calls for papers, but there's also some 'fluff'; the things that inspire, distract and keep us going. After all, while we may be dead serious academic types, we're human too.